Everyone at the Table: How Tabletop Exercises Strengthen Rural Water and Climate Resilience

Everyone at the Table: How Tabletop Exercises Strengthen Rural Water and Climate Resilience

November 2026
By: Shannon M. McNeeley, Delilah Griswold, Michelle Carroll-Cole, Madison Mooney

Key Takeaways

  • Rural communities cannot wait to prepare. Climate change is making extreme events more frequent and severe in rural regions like Central Appalachia. Floods, droughts, and freezes all threaten water systems that often have limited capacity to respond.
  • Preparedness is a whole-community effort. Water and climate resilience depends on many more people than utility staff and emergency managers. Health care providers, faith communities, local media, coroners, extension agents, and residents all play roles in a disaster, and they rarely plan together.
  • Tabletop exercises reveal what assets communities already have. Walking through a scenario together helps people find out about resources, procedures, and contacts they did not know existed. It also exposes the gaps in plans before a disaster hits.
  • Relationships are a community’s strongest resilience asset. Trusted local connectors and the conversations that happen while planning an exercise matter as much as the event itself. They build the trust people rely on when systems fail.
  • Inclusive planning strengthens community voice and accountability. Where decisions are often made from the top down, bringing community organizations, service providers, and public officials together gives a broader range of people a meaningful role in emergency planning.
  • Resilience needs follow-through. A single exercise is a starting point. Recurring exercises on different hazards and community resources such as resilience hubs help keep the momentum going.

Rural communities across the United States are facing more frequent and severe climate-driven disasters, from flash floods to prolonged droughts and extreme freezes. Each one puts pressure on water systems that are often small, aging, and run by limited staff and resources. In Eastern Kentucky, the July 2022 floods killed 45 people and left an estimated 18,000 water service connections without water, and another catastrophic flood in February 2025 knocked multiple wastewater systems offline, displaced hundreds of residents and took 23 lives. When a disaster strikes, the response depends on many people and organizations in the community, such as water operators, emergency managers and responders, health care workers, faith leaders, local radio hosts, and residents themselves. Tabletop exercises give communities a chance to bring these people together before a crisis, so they can learn who holds which resources, find the gaps in their plans, and build the trust they will need when water and sanitation systems fail. Yet these exercises are rarely held in rural places, and when they are, they seldom include the full community. The experience of one Appalachian county shows what a whole-community exercise can look like, and how any rural community can begin one.

Preparing for Floods in the Middle of One

On the evening of Thursday, September 24, 2026, community members from across Harlan County, Kentucky, gathered to practice how they would respond to a catastrophic flood in the first Harlan County Disaster Resilience Tabletop Exercise workshop, hosted by the Livelihoods Knowledge Exchange Network (LiKEN) in partnership with the Pacific Institute and the Rural Community Assistance Partnership (RCAP). At the same time, the county was living through a real flood event. On Monday, September 21, intense thunderstorms dropped up to 4.5 inches of rain on central Harlan County in under two hours, according to the National Weather Service, causing flash flooding in the communities of Coxton, Brookside, and Ages. Fire departments, law enforcement, and rescue squads carried out water rescues, homes were flooded, roads were heavily damaged, and two water lines broke. Fortunately, no lives were lost this time. The evening before the workshop, the National Weather Service issued additional flash flood warnings for Harlan County. During the workshop itself, several participants, including local emergency responders, law enforcement, and two state legislators, were called away to other emergencies and obligations, a reminder that the people who respond to disasters are often managing several demands at once.

Pictured: LiKEN facilitator Michelle Carroll-Cole welcomes participants at the first Harlan County Tabletop Exercise. Delilah Griswold of Pacific Institute takes notes. Photo credit: Madison Mooney

What is a Tabletop Exercise?

A tabletop exercise (TTX) is a structured, facilitated discussion in which people who respond to an emergency walk through a simulated scenario together. The simulation creates the opportunity to gain clarity in a calm setting, where it is okay to not know all the answers, and where the focus is on learning and information sharing – not blame or testing of expertise. Participants talk through what they would do, who they would call, and what resources they would need at each stage of a disaster.

Working through a scenario before a disaster helps reveal gaps in plans, resources, capacity, and knowledge. It clarifies who is responsible for what. It builds relationships among the people who will need to rely on one another when an emergency strikes. It can also reduce panic when a real emergency hits, because people have already practiced making decisions under pressure. Many tabletop exercises focus on utility staff and emergency managers. The Harlan TTX expanded this by including a deeper cross-section of the full community and institutions that serve them.

The Harlan County TTX Workshop

The Harlan County exercise was built around a real catastrophic flooding event. Rather than inventing a hypothetical storm, the scenario retraced the flood of February 14 to 17, 2025, when the Poor Fork of the Cumberland River reached major flood stage and Harlan County recorded the highest monthly precipitation total in the state. Participants were not imagining a disaster but revisiting one that their community had experienced just a year and a half earlier. Facilitated by LiKEN’s Community Engagement Coordinator, a lifelong Harlan County resident, the exercise asked participants to step into their professional roles and walk through the event day by day –  from the first warnings through road closures, rising water, and finally damage assessment and recovery.

The goals of the Harlan exercise were to:

  • Build community-wide preparedness for catastrophic flooding
  • Bring together people who do not typically connect
  • Widen participants’ understanding of one another’s roles, capacities, and resources
  • Build trust and relationships that hold up when a disaster strikes

The workshop was part of the five-year Water and Climate Equity in Rural Communities in the United States project and was co-developed by LiKEN, the Pacific Institute, and RCAP.  Through community assessment and participatory action research, the project identified key leverage points for building water resilience, including strong local leadership, ongoing community engagement, and tools that support community input. The tabletop exercise put those findings into practice. It also drew on the Harlan County Water Resilience Toolkit, whose Water Emergency section helps residents and community leaders understand what to do during floods, contamination, main line breaks, and water shortages. Every participant received a QR code linking to the Toolkit.

Participants gathered at the Harlan County Extension Depot in the evening for a shared meal and informal introductions. Facilitators then guided participants through a single scenario unfolding in five stages, each tied to a real day during the February 2025 flood: 1) pre-event conditions on Friday (February 14) as heavy rain fell on already saturated ground and the governor declared a state of emergency; 2) the first flash flood warnings and rising rivers on Saturday (February 15); 3) road closures and a landslide that cut off access, including to two local fire departments, later that same day; 4) continued flooding and water-system disruptions on Sunday (February 16); and 5) damage assessment, public information, and recovery on Monday (February 17).

Within each stage, LiKEN staff delivered “injects,” cards describing unexpected developments that specific participants had to address as they would in real life. In one, a landslide struck a water tank, leaving it leaning toward the rising river. In another, a water main break in the city of Harlan cut off water to half the town, including the hospital. Later injects asked participants how they would respond when a flood gate failed to close and when a major bridge leading to the hospital suffered structural damage. After each stage, the whole group came together to report out what they would do, what they had learned, and what questions remained.

Pictured: Harlan County Extension Agent Jeremy Williams strategizes with members of the Sunshine Fire Department at the Harlan County tabletop exercise. Photo credit: Madison Mooney

Who Was in the Room

Thirty-one community stakeholders took part, along with LiKEN and Pacific Institute staff, for a total of 37 people in the room. They represented a broad cross-section of the county:

  • Emergency response: police, fire, emergency management personnel
  • Health care: hospital and rehabilitation center/nursing home
  • Disaster relief: American Red Cross
  • Water and infrastructure: state water division and local water district, local water and sanitation providers
  • Coroners and funeral homes
  • Faith communities and outreach workers
  • Local radio
  • County agriculture extension
  • Nonprofit organizations: local, regional, national
  • Elected officials and legislators

The range of participants demonstrates how many people have a stake in flood response in a rural area and the diversity of organizations and agencies involved in disaster preparedness and response.

Pictured: Over thirty community members participated in a tabletop exercise facilitated by LiKEN Knowledge at the Harlan County Extension Depot. Photo Credit: Phill Barnett

What Participants Learned

Throughout the evening, participants discovered resources, procedures, and connections that many of them had not known existed. Several exchanges stood out:

Water systems as the backbone of emergency response: The water-related injects showed how one failure can ripple across a community. When a water main break cut service to the hospital, participants learned that a neighboring water utility could backfeed water to the hospital and other critical facilities. When a landslide toppled a water tank into the river, a local water plant operator walked through its response: making sure employees were safe, consulting the Kentucky Division of Water, and issuing a boil water advisory. Participants learned that the Division of Water can bring in mobile water treatment trailers, and the National Guard can deliver drinking water. The group also discussed facilities that cannot simply close or evacuate during an outage, such as the local detention center and recovery center. As the discussion made clear, water system failures cause more system failures.

Local radio as an emergency lifeline: When participants considered how to reach residents who lose internet access, cell service, or social media during a flood, local radio emerged as a critical link. A representative of the local radio station explained that the station would coordinate with the county judge-executive and emergency management to announce which areas were flooding and where displaced residents could find shelter. Participants also learned that amateur radio operators, commonly known as ham radio operators, can report to the county’s emergency operations center, which is equipped with ham and VHF/UHF radios, to keep communication open when other systems fail.

Caring for the most vulnerable residents: Staff from a nursing and rehabilitation facility next door to the hospital described how they would prepare for a flood. They would check how close the water was to the building, plan for 1.5 gallons of drinking water per resident per day along with a supply of non-potable water and rely on agreements with local churches and schools for buses if residents needed to be evacuated. Their biggest concern was not supplies but staffing: if staff levels dropped below the required minimum, they would have to scale back to essential care only. When a TTX scenario inject indicated that a major bridge leading to the hospital had been damaged, participants discussed coordinating with state highway officials to restore access.

Recovery support for displaced families: In the final stage, an inject asked how the community would support 30 families who had lost their homes or been displaced. Participants learned how local and national organizations fit together in recovery. The American Red Cross explained that it distributes food and cleaning supplies and, when its shelters close, works with the local housing authority to help residents find new homes, sometimes covering a security deposit or first month’s rent. A local faith-based outreach organization described the shelf-stable food and blankets it could provide, along with volunteers and a box truck through partner organizations. Participants also discussed how the Red Cross can replace supplies that local groups contribute during a disaster.

The questions raised by the exercise were just as valuable as the answers. Participants learned things about one another’s roles and responsibilities that many had not known before, and they also left with questions that will need to be clarified and addressed. For example, a discussion about the county’s floodgates revealed uncertainty about who is responsible for closing them. For 30 years, the cities of Harlan and Loyall were responsible for closing the gates, but since the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers recently turned over the levee system to the county, the order to close them now flows from the county judge executive’s office with advice from the emergency management agent. County road workers now do the physical closing of the gates, but still need assistance from the experienced city crews. During the exercise, a captain from another local fire department said he had not known about the change. Gaps like this are easy to miss until an emergency exposes them. As LiKEN’s Community Engagement Coordinator reflected afterward, the exercise was not about having all the answers. It was about identifying gaps, asking questions, and learning from one another. Those open questions give the community a clear starting point for the work ahead.

The exercise’s impact reached beyond disaster preparedness. In Harlan County, which has a long history of extractive industries, local governance is often top-down. Research through the project found that residents do not always have access to information about the water systems that serve them, and many do not feel they have a voice in decisions about them. The tabletop exercise helped level the playing field. Participants from every sector worked through the same problem as equals, in a format built on collaboration rather than on testing expertise or assigning blame. Everyone in the room was given a forum to both speak and listen, and those who often remain silent are now asking for more.

What Made It Work, and What We Would Change

Bringing a full cross-section of the county to the table took more than sending invitations. Two factors made the difference in who came and how fully they took part.

  1. A trusted community connector: Having a local organizer with lifelong ties to the community brought deep, long-standing relationships throughout the county. This shows that one of the strongest assets in rural disaster preparedness and response is the relationships people already have.
  2. Building buy-in before the event: The planning process itself did important work. Conversations while organizing the exercise connected people, raised awareness of shared risks, and surfaced community concerns, including about local water quality. Community members were committed to the outcomes of the event before they even sat down at the table.
Pictured: Sheriff Chris Brewer shares a lighter moment with members of the Sunshine Fire Department at the Harlan County tabletop exercise facilitated by LiKEN Knowledge. Photo Credit: Madison Mooney

As organizers, we also took away several lessons that will shape future exercises:

More time for introductions: Participants need to know who is in the room before they can work together. A longer event, while demanding more of people’s time, would allow for this.

More room to move: The greatest value came from connections made across tables. Future exercises will build in more reasons for participants to leave their seats and meet people beyond those sitting next to them.

Deeper engagement from elected leaders: Both state legislators attended but were called away partway through the evening. Local and state leaders hold key resources and decisions, and their full participation would strengthen future exercises and the trust they are meant to build.

Backup participants for key roles: Not every expected role was filled on the night. For example, the county’s agricultural extension agent stepped in to cover several, drawing on more than 15 years of disaster preparedness training. An American Red Cross representative stepped in to role play as law enforcement when they were called away to an emergency. Future exercises would benefit from identifying backups in advance.

These lessons will guide future exercises in Harlan County and could help other rural communities design their own.

Next Steps to Keep Momentum for Building Resilience

The tabletop exercise was a starting point, not an endpoint. Building lasting resilience will require continued opportunities to strengthen relationships, share resources, and turn what participants learned into action. To carry this momentum forward, LiKEN and the Pacific Institute plan to:

Survey participants and share a summary report: Participants completed a short evaluation at the end of the evening. A short follow-up survey will capture the resources, contacts, and procedures that did not come up because of time limits. LiKEN will share a brief summary report of lessons learned and key takeaways with everyone who attended.

Explore an annual tabletop exercise in Harlan County: Future exercises could address other hazards that threaten local water systems, such as droughts and extreme freezes, with topics chosen by participants. Holding the exercise each year would also put lessons learned from organizing the first exercise into practice and deepen the relationships built through it.

Consider a community resilience hub: A trusted local place for information, supplies, and coordination before, during, and after disasters will provide a head start when disaster strikes. Rural communities across Appalachia are already building them. In Floyd County, Kentucky, residents received $100,000 to develop a hub that will support people affected by flooding and serve as a center for sharing resilience strategies. In western North Carolina, the Celo Community Center became one of the region’s first resilience hubs with permanent solar power, giving it backup energy when the grid goes down.

Strengthen two-way communication between residents and water systems: Continue supporting transparent communication among residents, local government, and water utilities, using tools such as LiKEN’s Community Engagement Guide and Water Resilience Toolkit, which helps communities organize meetings, understand their water and wastewater systems, and request public information. The goal is to carry the collaboration built at the exercise into everyday decisions about water.

Whether the next step is a follow-up survey, a second exercise, or a resilience hub, each one starts in the same place: knowing who to call when the next disaster arrives.

Preparedness Built on Relationships

In sum, floods, droughts, and extreme freezes will keep testing Harlan County’s water systems, and climate change is making extreme weather more frequent and severe. The TTX showed that it already has much of what it needs to meet these challenges: people who care, deep local knowledge, community assets, and a willingness to show up. A TTX gives those strengths a place to connect before the next disaster strikes. The same opportunity exists in small towns and rural regions across the United States and around the world, where water systems are often stretched thin and the people who respond to emergencies may rarely sit in the same room. Preparing does not require large budgets or elaborate drills. With a shared meal, a realistic scenario, and everyone at the table, any community can begin building the relationships and capacity that resilience depends on.

Learn more about the Water and Climate Equity in Rural Communities in the US project, Pacific Institute’s Water and Climate Equity work, and LiKEN’s Water Collaboratory.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank the community members in Harlan County who attended the TTX event and made it successful, especially since this took place after business hours. We thank Deborah Thompson, LiKEN’s Impact Director, and Betsy Taylor, LiKEN’s Director, who helped shape the event and generously reviewed this post. We are grateful to RCAP for their guidance, input, and feedback on the TTX materials and workshop. Thanks also to LiKEN’s Communications Director Phill Barnett, and the Pacific Institute Strategic Communications and Outreach team for helping this work reach decision makers and others who can drive change toward a more resilient world. This work was generously supported by the BHP Foundation.


Scroll to Top
Pacific Institute
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.