Pacific Institute Insights

National Geographic ScienceBlog: The Impacts of California’s Drought on Hydroelectricity Production

By Peter Gleick, President

March 17, 2015

California’s hottest and driest drought in recorded history has shifted the sources of electricity with adverse economic and environmental consequences. The Pacific Institute has just completed and released a report that evaluates how diminished river flows have resulted in less hydroelectricity, more expensive electricity from the combustion of natural gas, and increased production of greenhouse gas emissions.

The current severe drought has many negative consequences. One of them that receives little attention is how the drought has fundamentally changed the way our electricity is produced. Under normal conditions, electricity for the state’s millions of users is produced from a blend of sources, with natural gas and hydropower being the top two. Since the drought has reduced the state’s river flows that power hundreds of hydropower stations, natural gas has become a more prominent player in the mix. This is an expensive change.

According to the Institute’s report, between October 2011 and October 2014, California’s ratepayers spent $1.4 billion more for electricity than in average years because of the drought-induced shift from hydropower to natural gas. In an average year, hydropower provides around 18 percent of the electricity needed for agriculture, industry, and homes. Comparatively, in this three-year drought period, hydropower made up less than 12 percent of total California electricity generation. The figure below (Figure 6 from the new study) shows the monthly anomalies in state hydropower generation in wet and dry years, and the severe cuts over the past three years.

The decrease in monthly hydroelectric generation over the past three years can be seen clearly in this figure. Losses in the past three years have totaled 34,000 GWh and $1.4 billion dollars.

A longer view reveals an even more startling economic impact: factoring in the dry years from 2007-2009, the total additional energy cost to the state’s electricity users during the six years of recent drought was $2.4 billion.

This increased reliance on natural gas for the state’s electricity production also has environmental costs. Hydropower has some well-known environmental impacts, especially on rivers and aquatic ecosystems, but it produces few or no air contaminants, whereas burning natural gas emits many pollutants, including climate-changing greenhouse gases. During the 2011- 2014 drought period, burning more natural gas to compensate for limited hydropower led to an eight-percent increase in emissions of carbon dioxide and other pollutants from California power plants.

If the current drought persists, water flowing to drive hydroelectric turbines will continue to shrink and expensive and polluting natural gas will become even more of a factor in the electricity production game.

The full report can be downloaded free here: http://pacinst.org/news/new-report-reveals-drought-increases-energy-costs-and-climate-changing-pollution/.

One Response

  1. Neil Brackin says:

    Mr. Gleick,

    Although not the magic bullet many are looking for with regards to drought relief, a well executed and managed cloud seeding program is a real solution that needs to more widely adopted in California. We have been participating in cloud seeding in California for over a decade, however most projects are fragmented and under funded to realize the true results available with larger scale. Cloud seeding is proven with science and has a well vetted environmental record from numerous third party studies. The ONLY way to replenish our waterways and ground water supplies is through additonal atmospheric water. Operational cloud seeding should be part of all stakeholders water management program and is available today.
    I welcome your feedback and dialogue on this topic, please see this current article as just one example of this technology delivering for a hydro-power company in the western U.S:

    http://magicvalley.com/news/local/cloud-seeding-pays-off/article_dbb25276-a23f-57ca-8886-d8e75d3b5f78.html

    Best Regards,

    Neil Brackin
    612.845.1631

Leave a Reply